Ask DS AC central air

[2dogs]

My AC compessor is burned out, it's a 13 yr old Carrier and I need a new unit. I have always heard that a Trane is the top of the line, I would appreciate opinions on the best bang for the buck on cental AC units. Thanks

[ntzhunter]

I've been told that Carrier is top of the line. I have a Rheem that is 17 yrs old and I plan to go with a Rheem again.

[Faithful Retrievers]

I put trane in my office and my house an I have been pleased. I think it depends on who you get one guy carried Rheem one guy carried trane that I had price mine. I prob doubt their is too much difference. I went with the trane guy cause he runs a better operation for installation and service. There are a ton of options just in the trane. I went with just the mid grade.

[GreenheadJim]

My AC compessor is burned out, it's a 13 yr old Carrier and I need a new unit. I have always heard that a Trane is the top of the line, I would appreciate opinions on the best bang for the buck on cental AC units. Thanks

Just keep this in mind, all coils are made by the same company and then sold to Trane, Carrier, Rheem, etc. I work for a company that builds evaporator and condensor coils and we manufacture for all of the companies. They just put their name on it.

[ntzhunter]

My AC compessor is burned out, it's a 13 yr old Carrier and I need a new unit. I have always heard that a Trane is the top of the line, I would appreciate opinions on the best bang for the buck on cental AC units. Thanks

Just keep this in mind, all coils are made by the same company and then sold to Trane, Carrier, Rheem, etc. I work for a company that builds evaporator and condensor coils and we manufacture for all of the companies. They just put their name on it.

Interesting. So a cheaper Goodman has the same guts as a Trane/Rheem, etc?

[jtdumallard]

My AC compessor is burned out, it's a 13 yr old Carrier and I need a new unit. I have always heard that a Trane is the top of the line, I would appreciate opinions on the best bang for the buck on cental AC units. Thanks

Just keep this in mind, all coils are made by the same company and then sold to Trane, Carrier, Rheem, etc. I work for a company that builds evaporator and condensor coils and we manufacture for all of the companies. They just put their name on it.

Interesting. So a cheaper Goodman has the same guts as a Trane/Rheem, etc?

bingo!!!!!!

[deltadukman]

Goodman has a good warranty, but thats a good thing because you'll need it. Ours at our office and the other suites are always needing something every summer and they are only 6-7 years old.

[JLT]

Not enough difference in any of them to spit at.

[Muddy Boots]

Replaced my 19 year old Trane with another Trane last month. Had some repairs the last three years. It was time for a new one. Had it done by Evans AC out of Hamilton MS. Very pleased.

[Deltaquack]

My AC compessor is burned out, it's a 13 yr old Carrier and I need a new unit. I have always heard that a Trane is the top of the line, I would appreciate opinions on the best bang for the buck on cental AC units. Thanks

Just keep this in mind, all coils are made by the same company and then sold to Trane, Carrier, Rheem, etc. I work for a company that builds evaporator and condensor coils and we manufacture for all of the companies. They just put their name on it.

Yep, just look for whatever dealer provides the best service in your area. I've had Carrier, Rheem, and Lennox. I sold my house a couple of years ago and had bought it from the guy that built it for himself. The people I sold it to called a Lennox dealer to come service them a year later. Well, that dealer told them that all the coils in the units were generic and needed to be replaced with Lennox brand coils (I'm not joking). So, they paid like $13,000 to have all 4 or 5 ac units' coils replaced and whatever else. They were then mad at me b/c I supposedly screwed them over with generic coils. I couldn't stop laughing b/c they were gullible enough to believe what the dealer sold them on.

[brake man]

Most of the named units are good equipment and should have a reasonable life expectancy. I sell the large commercial Carrier equipment so I am partial to Carrier but that is just my own bias. Note that Trane replacement parts are typically much more expensive than for other equipment manufacturers listed. Lennox parts are typically much harder to find for some reason and can also be more expensive. Goodman actually makes a very good unit. Consider a dual-fuel/hybrid heat pump unit if you have natural gas available. This unit will heat and cool with the refrigeration system (quite efficient) and will only switch to gas when the outdoor temperatures are freezing and below. More expensive unit but much better life cycle cost. Just 2 cents added to the discussion.

[Barq's]

Any of the units....installed correctly....will last for quite sometime. But a unit is only as good as the person installing it. Hence, you can take a Stainless Steel Maytag Unit, hook it up to an old system that burnt out with acid in the lineset, and you might not get 6 months out of the compressor....had nothing to do with the unit, but the knowledge and time used to either do the job right, or screw you with a quick fix and then never see the guy again.

Go with a reputable business....and Goodman makes just as good, if not better a unit than any of the others out there. Another thing to keep in mind, you need to make sure that the inside and outside match....if not, they won't ever work as efficient as they should and will run more than a "matched" set of equipment.

Anyone with an old "22" unit that has to buy a complete outside unit, should probably go ahead and replace the entire system with 410A....very soon, 22 is going to cost so much that you will be better off replacing it, than paying what it would cost to fill an old 22 system.

I know of apartment complexes that are being sold due to the expense of the a/c's alone....due to them being old and R22 systems.