waterfowlwidowmaker wrote:For once, I agree with you duckman. An old doe is one of the most challenging game animals there is. I have always enjoyed being able to harvest an old doe. I believe her keen sense of awareness and stealthy attitude presents a significant challenge. I swear, when I know I'm about to get a shot at a good sized doe, my heart races like a 180"er is standing in front of me.
I'm still in total disagreement about your views of "managing" your deer herd. But, everyone has their own views and has to do what they feel is right. As for me, I will continue to shoot a lot of does, cull bucks, and pass on the ones i feel have not met their potential development. I think this is the part of deer hunting I love so much. I love being able to watch deer grow and wonder what they will be like next year. Big racks are one thing, but to be able to confidently say that you had an impact on helping a mature deer develop the way he has through timber management, food plots, mineral licks, etc. is worth all the time and effort I put in to it each year.
For Once you agree.. Oh come on WM you have agreed more than your willing to admit.

We can disagree on Management that is fine, no one thinks the same all the time. I would rather have a man come in with a good 6 or 8 point than nothing at all because of some club restriction. After all it is called hunting.
I'll pat them on the back and say you are the man.... Trophy's are in the eyes of the boholder. I have no problem with anyone killing anything if they intend to use it for substance. It is the method that many times bothers me in how they achieve the kill. The heritage was created for all to enjoy and if a man gets pleasure from a small deer then that is what the heritage was put there for. Nothing wrong with those that choose to kill only old mature bucks. I think it is great leaves more for those that choose to shoot the smaller ones.
Our club has taken over two hundred in three years. Yet our game cameras are getting very nice bucks constantly and our food plots are being destroyed by the deer. Do you really think leaving a few medium size bucks is going to make a difference on 200 and 300 tracks of land?
I go for the camp social, the getting to the outdoors, and the love of the chase. Nothing better than a stringer of ducks in the morning and a deer after lunch. That WM is what it is all about, the antlers or nothing but bragging rights to me. Yes I love to shoot big deer and I'm satisfied when I do. I also get just as much enjoyment out of being in the skinning shed helping a man skin his four point because it meant something to him. The more primative the surroundings the better.
I have spent the last 7 weekends at camp building, disc, cutting, scouting, repairing waders decoy lines, and planting. It is a way of life, not a passtime for some. Not all people reach that level, not all want to.
You can see me anyway you want as most of you do anyway. The bottomline is I walk the walk that I talk. Most don't even come close.
Excuse me why I pat myself on the back...
