Page 3 of 4

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2012 1:21 pm
by richard b evers
FYI, south of Simpson County, I wonder if they are missing any thing?

MISSISSIPPI MARKET BULLETIN
EXOTIC LIVESTOCK & PETS
Raise Mississippi Red deer for pets or
profit, ready to deliver to your farm,
$495 & up depending on age & sex,
Marion Co.,

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2012 1:24 pm
by chevy01234
DUCKAHOLIC wrote:
SWomack wrote:A Red deer is livestock, not wildlife. When did it become LEGAL to shoot livestock? I guess by this standard one could go duck or goose hunting and shoot a hawk, eagle, turkey, or heron ..cause it's just a bigger bird. And then seek out the news media to have your photo taken. If you don't know what it is, don't shoot it.

You let one of them prize elk in Morton come to my place and watch how fast I shoot it.

And the Hawk, eagle etc etc thing is about them dumbest thing I have ever read..........now everyone on here is dumber than before from just haveing to read that..........

Bingo...It's an exotic, invasive species once it is outside of that fence as far as i'm concerned!

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2012 9:46 pm
by SWomack
DUCKAHOLIC wrote:
SWomack wrote:A Red deer is livestock, not wildlife. When did it become LEGAL to shoot livestock? I guess by this standard one could go duck or goose hunting and shoot a hawk, eagle, turkey, or heron ..cause it's just a bigger bird. And then seek out the news media to have your photo taken. If you don't know what it is, don't shoot it.

You let one of them prize elk in Morton come to my place and watch how fast I shoot it.

And the Hawk, eagle etc etc thing is about them dumbest thing I have ever read..........now everyone on here is dumber than before from just haveing to read that..........
A person who would think that, may not have the IQ, aptitude, or reading comprehension to follow and understand what I meant. We aren't talking about you, are we?

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2012 10:19 pm
by bolivarduck
SWomack wrote:
DUCKAHOLIC wrote:
SWomack wrote:A Red deer is livestock, not wildlife. When did it become LEGAL to shoot livestock? I guess by this standard one could go duck or goose hunting and shoot a hawk, eagle, turkey, or heron ..cause it's just a bigger bird. And then seek out the news media to have your photo taken. If you don't know what it is, don't shoot it.

You let one of them prize elk in Morton come to my place and watch how fast I shoot it.

And the Hawk, eagle etc etc thing is about them dumbest thing I have ever read..........now everyone on here is dumber than before from just haveing to read that..........
A person who would think that, may not have the IQ, aptitude, or reading comprehension to follow and understand what I meant. We aren't talking about you, are we?
SWomack, your argument absolutely fails to hold water due to the fact that the mourning dove is legal to shoot in MS, but the ring neck dove is considered an invasive species (outside of an enclosure and not native) and doesn't fall into the same bag limit. I would submit that as a comparison here to attempt to persuade you. Now, these guys did luck out... they shot an animal without having a CLUE as to what it was, but they did remark they believed it to be a (whitetail) deer. Not all hunters in MS are amateur biologists and we should be careful in giving people such a hard time- remember that the number of hunters is decreasing across the country and we should look to educate people rather than persecute them. This also goes for all those on here that jump at any little thing someone does (i.e. face paint, dogs, mojos, etc...) to make fun of them just because they don't do it the same as them.

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:06 pm
by deltadukman
SWomack wrote:
DUCKAHOLIC wrote:
SWomack wrote:A Red deer is livestock, not wildlife. When did it become LEGAL to shoot livestock? I guess by this standard one could go duck or goose hunting and shoot a hawk, eagle, turkey, or heron ..cause it's just a bigger bird. And then seek out the news media to have your photo taken. If you don't know what it is, don't shoot it.

You let one of them prize elk in Morton come to my place and watch how fast I shoot it.

And the Hawk, eagle etc etc thing is about them dumbest thing I have ever read..........now everyone on here is dumber than before from just haveing to read that..........
A person who would think that, may not have the IQ, aptitude, or reading comprehension to follow and understand what I meant. We aren't talking about you, are we?




When's the last time you saw people "farming" eagles and hawks?

pretty sure once its outside of the fence a good ways its fair game....not so much if youre hunying at the gate.......

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2012 11:25 pm
by mudsucker
I'da shot dat sumbitch! :shock:

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 10:50 am
by SWomack
So if a hunter decides to shoot a wild hog in the fading light and shoots a black bear by mistake, by your logic it would be ok? I believed it was a hog, I know I shot it, but it really isn't my responsibilty to identify what I am shooting, duh... That is how hunting accidents happen. What if it had been a 500 pound brown calf? All I am saying is they shot a Red Deer, which is livestock not wildlife that is not a game animal in season. I doubt criminal charges will be brought against anyone in this case but some food for thought for those who just think they can start blasting away at 500 pound animals of unknown species....it could be construed as a felony.

http://www.mscode.com/free/statutes/97/041/0015.htm
MISSISSIPPI CODE OF 1972
As Amended

SEC. 97-41-15. Malicious or mischievous injury to livestock; penalty; restitution.

(1) Any person who shall maliciously, either out of a spirit of revenge or wanton cruelty, or who shall mischievously kill, maim or wound, or injure any livestock, or cause any person to do the same, shall be guilty of a felony and upon conviction, shall be committed to the custody of the State Department of Corrections for not less than twelve (12) months nor more than five years, and fined an amount not less than One Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($1,500.00), nor more than Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000.00).


(2) In addition to any such fine or imprisonment which may be imposed, the court shall order that restitution be made to the owner of any animal listed in subsection (1) of this section. The measure for restitution in money shall be the current replacement value of such loss and/or the actual veterinarian fees, special supplies, loss of income and other costs incurred as a result of actions in violation of subsection (1) of this section.


(3) For purposes of this section, the term "livestock" shall mean horses, cattle, swine, sheep and other domestic animals produced for profit.


SOURCES: Codes, Hutchinson's 1848, ch. 64, art. 7(1); 1857, ch. 64, art. 201; 1871, Sec. 8708; 1880, Sec. 2917; 1892, Sec. 1022; 1906, Sec. 1099; Hemingway's 1917, Sec. 825; 1930, Sec. 849; 1942, Sec. 2075; Laws, 1981, ch 448, Sec. 1; 1993, ch. 438, Sec. 2, eff from and after July 1, 1993.

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:00 am
by GrizwalD
who ever said red deer are live stock ..... just because someone throws up a fence and puts red deer in it doesnt make them livestock ..... they arent domesticated animals

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:23 am
by edub20
GrizwalD wrote:who ever said red deer are live stock ..... just because someone throws up a fence and puts red deer in it doesnt make them livestock ..... they arent domesticated animals
never seen any at the auctions

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:38 am
by MisterBlack
MSDawg870 wrote:Dey gon bar b que dat whole muddafugga???
hahahaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahaa.

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:45 am
by MisterBlack
feedcall wrote:....and Albert Pujols was with them for the whole thing. Man, what a great day for that guy.

bwhahahaha x's 2

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:47 am
by duramax
SWomack wrote:So if a hunter decides to shoot a wild hog in the fading light and shoots a black bear by mistake, by your logic it would be ok? I believed it was a hog, I know I shot it, but it really isn't my responsibilty to identify what I am shooting, duh... That is how hunting accidents happen. What if it had been a 500 pound brown calf? All I am saying is they shot a Red Deer, which is livestock not wildlife that is not a game animal in season. I doubt criminal charges will be brought against anyone in this case but some food for thought for those who just think they can start blasting away at 500 pound animals of unknown species....it could be construed as a felony.
A bear is an indigenous protected species in Mississippi. Killing one in Mississippi is illegal. They are native to Mississippi. Red Deer is for one thing, not live stock, it is catagorized as an exotic, and is not subject to seasons or limits. I don't know what the laws are regarding killing someones cow that is on your property, but cows aren't exotic species, they are livestock, and significantly different, and therefore much more difficult to mistake for a deer. After all, a Red Deer is in fact, a deer. To someone who has never seen a Red Deer, or in their case, probably any type of deer other than a white-tail. Why would they think anything different when the only deer that are supposed to be in Mississippi are Whitetails.

You're logic makes no sense.

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:51 am
by JaMak84
SWomack wrote:So if a hunter decides to shoot a wild hog in the fading light and shoots a black bear by mistake, by your logic it would be ok? I believed it was a hog, I know I shot it, but it really isn't my responsibilty to identify what I am shooting, duh... That is how hunting accidents happen. What if it had been a 500 pound brown calf? All I am saying is they shot a Red Deer, which is livestock (no it's not, per the definition of "livestock" you posted below in this very response) :? not wildlife that is not a game animal in season. I doubt criminal charges will be brought against anyone in this case but some food for thought for those who just think they can start blasting away at 500 pound animals of unknown species....it could be construed as a felony.

http://www.mscode.com/free/statutes/97/041/0015.htm
MISSISSIPPI CODE OF 1972
As Amended

SEC. 97-41-15. Malicious or mischievous injury to livestock; penalty; restitution.

(1) Any person who shall maliciously, either out of a spirit of revenge or wanton cruelty, or who shall mischievously kill, maim or wound, or injure any livestock, or cause any person to do the same, shall be guilty of a felony and upon conviction, shall be committed to the custody of the State Department of Corrections for not less than twelve (12) months nor more than five years, and fined an amount not less than One Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($1,500.00), nor more than Ten Thousand Dollars ($10,000.00).


(2) In addition to any such fine or imprisonment which may be imposed, the court shall order that restitution be made to the owner of any animal listed in subsection (1) of this section. The measure for restitution in money shall be the current replacement value of such loss and/or the actual veterinarian fees, special supplies, loss of income and other costs incurred as a result of actions in violation of subsection (1) of this section.


(3) For purposes of this section, the term "livestock" shall mean horses, cattle, swine, sheep and other domestic animals produced for profit.


SOURCES: Codes, Hutchinson's 1848, ch. 64, art. 7(1); 1857, ch. 64, art. 201; 1871, Sec. 8708; 1880, Sec. 2917; 1892, Sec. 1022; 1906, Sec. 1099; Hemingway's 1917, Sec. 825; 1930, Sec. 849; 1942, Sec. 2075; Laws, 1981, ch 448, Sec. 1; 1993, ch. 438, Sec. 2, eff from and after July 1, 1993.

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 11:53 am
by woundedduck
If I, "accidentally", shot another's cow on my property..........I would be eating a chitload of steak!

Re: 500 lb deer killed in Simpson County

Posted: Fri Jan 06, 2012 12:08 pm
by duramax
JaMak84 wrote:(no it's not, per the definition of "livestock" you posted below in this very response) :?
Exactly. Last time I checked, a Red deer is not a "horse, cattle, swine, sheep and other domestic animals produced for profit." I don't think a Red deer falls under the category of a domestic animal hahaha. :lol: I don't think I want a red deer living in my house.